Home > Case Book > Consumer Protection for Vulnerable People: A Case Scenario

Consumer Protection for Vulnerable People: A Case Scenario

By: Mary Williams BA (hons) - Updated: 17 Sep 2012 | comments*Discuss
Vulnerable Contract Elderly Cancellation

Anyone who has elderly or vulnerable relatives worries that they might be taken advantage of by unscrupulous sales people, trying to make a fast buck from people who might be more trusting than the average cowboy trader savvy consumer.

A Common Scam Involving Vulnerable People

It’s quite common for security firms to target the elderly, because they know that elderly people can be concerned about their safety, especially those who live alone and who may be concerned that they could fall prey to burglars or intruders. One fairly common ploy for less scrupulous security firms is to target areas with a high population of elderly residents, and keep an eye on the properties where they can identify that there are lone residents, who don’t seem to get many visitors.

They will research crime figures so that they can use them to frighten people into thinking that they are at risk from burglars...then target the most vulnerable people.

One company targeted a vulnerable elderly lady we’ll call Mrs Smith, who was in her eighties, partially sighted and deaf. She lived alone, and luckily for Mrs Smith, she had a caring family who kept a look out for her. But she was still talked into buying a totally unnecessary security system by an unscrupulous salesman.

The sales patter involved the sales man frightening Mrs Smith into believing that the crime figures in her area were high and on the rise, and that they had had a quick look around her property and identified several areas where security was lax and could leave her property vulnerable to crime.

After frightening Mrs Smith, the sales man reassured her that she would be able to drastically cut her risk of falling victim to crime by installing their system. The equipment that he sold her actually included a video entry system – remember that Mrs Smith was partially sighted! Pressurised into agreeing and signing on the dotted line, the sales man got his vulnerable target and Mrs Smith agreed to installation of everything that the sales man offered her. At a vastly inflated price. Not only this, but she was actually asked for a cash deposit up front, and the sales man went with her to the cash point to get the money. This practice used to be extremely common.

When Mrs Smith’s daughter found out what her vulnerable mother had been signed up to, she was furious and contacted the company to cancel the contract. They refused to speak to her on the grounds that she wasn’t the customer, and that Mrs Smith has willingly entered into a contract which they would be enforcing.

Legally, the law has been tightened to protect vulnerable consumers and to discourage pressure sales techniques. If anyone sells you goods or services that cost over £35 in total (you have extra legal rights according to the Cancellation of Contracts made in a Consumer's home or place of work etc. Regulations. You must have written notice of your cancellation rights, and you automatically have at least seven days to cancel the contract if you change your mind. If you don’t receive the written notice, you can’t be held to the contract even if you cancel it more than seven days later. These rules even apply to traders that you have invited into your home, although there are some exceptions – you will have to pay for anything you’ve received if you buy:

  • goods that are needed for emergency purposes
  • goods have been made to your specification
  • any perishable goods
  • goods which are consumed and can’t be returned
  • goods that have been incorporated into land
  • any goods or services relating to a funeral
In this case, Mrs Smith wasn’t given any details of cancellation rights, so her daughter informed Trading Standards, but also wrote a letter on her mother’s behalf, asking for the return of the deposit plus cancellation of the contract.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • Kath
    Re: What If Your Plumber Makes Mistakes?
    I have a completely new bathroom fitted and everything seems to be wrong and all the other bathroom companies who have…
    20 March 2019
  • Mws
    Re: Buying a New Car: Your Rights
    I’ve just found out that my jaguar is being recalled as the published emissions are significantly higher that advertised in real…
    18 March 2019
  • Jenny
    Re: A Guide to the Consumer Rights Act 2015
    We bought my platinum and diamond engagement ring in June 2018. We got engaged in January this year so I have only…
    14 March 2019
  • Sad lady
    Re: When Am I Not Entitled to a Refund?
    I bought a sofa that would easily fit into my room. I was given very basic measurements by the seller. I have a normal…
    12 March 2019
  • Shell
    Re: What If Your Plumber Makes Mistakes?
    We bought a new build 3 years ago and we have just had a leak coming through our living room ceiling. We contacted the…
    28 February 2019
  • Aga
    Re: The Fake EHIC Card Scam
    This happed also to me:/ I used just yesterday this scam service, wasn't sure maybe a some of the low about " free of charged" been…
    27 February 2019
  • Ido
    Re: The Fake EHIC Card Scam
    I have just been scammed. The website seemed official. They charged me 24.50 to renew. I only discovered today when I received the card…
    22 February 2019
  • Annetta
    Re: Buying a Used Car: Your Rights
    I bought a car in August last year after a week i discovered a faults garage offering to help but that was 4 hours away from him…
    20 February 2019
  • Nik
    Re: How to Complain
    Purchased oak coloured laminated flooring from retailer who fitted it over a large area. 7 years on the ends of some planks have faded at an angle,…
    20 February 2019
  • BigAl
    Re: The Fake EHIC Card Scam
    I too have been caught by this scan at the cost of £27.50. The website looks official and is clearly still up and running on the 14/02/19…
    19 February 2019